|
|
|
The Original American In ParisThe Story of George Antheil
A Documentary Feature for BBC Radio 3
by Maxwell Steer © 1988Part Three
A spacious carpeted room, party FX
- FRIEDE
- There'd been a party at my apartment - this was in December of 1926 - and Aaron Copland had played George's Sonata Sauvage. Even on my baby grand it sounded exciting.
- COPLAND
- Okay Donald. Why not bring him over? There must be thousands of people who want to hear his Ballet Mécanique. I'll bet you could even fill Carnegie Hall.
- FRIEDE
- Hey, that's not such a bad idea. Know his address?
- COPLAND
- If you cable him care of Shakespeare & Company. Sylvia'll know where he is.
Friede neutral, Antheil in a largish room
- FRIEDE
- 3 days later I got an answer from Budapest: he was ready to leave as soon as transportation was forthcoming. And so began the saga of the American premiere of Ballet Mécanique. From the very beginning it was quite extraordinary. Within 24 hours I had booked Carnegie Hall for April 10th, and sent Steamship reservations to George & Boski. All I needed now were the musicians.
-
I knew that the Ballet Mécanique was scored for an incredible collection of instruments - how incredible I was to find out later. Eugene Goossens was engaged as conductor and we hired 6 xylophonists, 2 bass drummers, and some very fine pianists, including Aaron himself. But I couldn't make head or tail of George's demands for things like electric bells and a fire siren, so we left all that until his arrival.
MUS 12 JAZZ SYMPHONY Disc: Telefunken 6.42196 with edits Hold then dialog over
- I was also keen to premiere George's Jazz Symphony, which was very much in the temper of the times. I cant remember who suggested getting WC Handy, but it struck us as an excellent idea - surely the man who wrote St Louis Blues would understand a Jazz Symphony. Handy had soon assembled a truly wonderful orchestra of coloured jazzmen, and himself seemed quite unfazed by the intricacies of the score. It was only later we were to find out why! All thru the mad days of rehearsals, interviews and parties Antheil drifted in a daze, overcome, I regret to say, by my sheer exuberance and cocksureness.
- ANTHEIL
- How wise my old doctor in Paris had been to insist on 6 months' rest. Had I been feeling stronger I would have protested, but it was all like a dream, in which I was swept along by a powerful tide of events.
- FRIEDE
- I subscribed to the good all-American belief that any publicity was good publicity, as long as they spelled your name right. But in publicising a musical event as I would have a book, I utterly failed to appreciate the difference between promoting a known commodity that had already been created, and one which required the sensitive collaboration of the public in its creation. By seeming to turn a serious performance into a circus I was already alienating the critics and jeopardising George's whole future in America.
- ANTHEIL
- Of the performance itself, the less said the better. After the weeks of when I couldn't open a newspaper or a magazine without seeing my name, and had had to endure ever more sensationalised repetitions of my european career, the public had been drawn not by musical expectations, but rather by promises of some kind of gladiatorial spectacle or vaudeville show.
-
For such an audience, a String Quartet was a hideously bad choice to open with. Next I was to accompany my 2nd Violin Sonata. Ordinarily, it would've been duck soup for me, but Donald's physician, noting my low physical condition, thought it well to give me some glandular injection at the last moment, which he most unfortunately gave me in the right arm. This caused my arm to swell and made every note I played an exquisite torture, but contributed no new energy whatever.
-
MUS 12 Coda Jazz Symphony
-
The 1st half concluded with the Jazz Symphony, which was quite well received. But during the interval all that good work was undone by the infernal scenery.
-
FRIEDE
-
To our chagrin we found that the backdrops could not be changed over without raising the front curtain. Word quickly spread around the lobbies that there were strange doings to be seen onstage, with the result that the entire audience trooped back in to watch. It was a bad introduction, but worse was to follow.
-
MUS 13 Ballet Mécanique
-
For the first few minutes they listened carefully. But when the moment came for the wind machine to be turned on, I bitterly regretted that we had agreed to the publicity agent's suggestion of a real aircraft propeller, the more so because the darn thing was found to be pointing right at the audience. As it slowly gathered speed people clutched their programs, women held onto their hats. One man tied a white handkerchief to his cane and waved it wildly as a sign of mock-surrender. Eventually the operator was able to redirect the blast ...
-
ANTHEIL
-
But the damage had been done. A kind of hysterical laughter spread contagiously. It was agonising. Serious concert-goers began to leave. I wished with all my heart that I had never heard of Donald Friede. But the crowning indignity was saved until last.
-
FRIEDE
-
George's score calls for a siren towards the end. Getting a portable one had caused endless trouble, and we'd only just gotten a New Jersey Fire Department siren late on this very day.
-
FX of siren?
-
On cue the man turned the crank, but nothing happened. He wound it more and more vigorously. As he redoubled his efforts so the mirth of the audience grew more hysterical. At last, just before the end, he stopt. But what he had in fact been doing was setting in motion a great flywheel which now could not be arrested. The sound first emerged with a menacing growl, which rose steadily in stridency and volume, completely drowning the end of the piece, but reserving its full force for the moment when Antheil & Goossens stood to take their bow. The noise was devastating & painful. Applause was out of the question, people were running for the exits covering their ears with their hands.
-
MUS /FX Conclude
-
-
ANTHEIL
-
Few people bothered to consider the whole experience objectively, but one of those who did was the writer William Carlos Williams.
In an office
- WILLIAMS
- Naturally they claimed that the critics had heard nothing, which was probably quite true. Certainly, I did not seek to have them favor Antheil. I really did not. But I did expect their criticism to be about music - to say somewhere what the works might have been about even if they were failures. It is their inability even to come in contact with the problem and not their unfavourable comments which disturbs me.
-
If it had been Beethoven we should, no doubt, have been alleviated and strengthened against Life - the enemy. And, going out into the subway we should for a moment have withstood the assault as the strength of the music died. Tho we may even have felt its benediction a week long.
But as I came from Antheil's concert a musician of our party remarked "The subway seems sweet after that." And this is what I noted - the unrelated noise of life such as in this subway had not been battened out as would have been the case with Beethoven still warm in the mind but actually it had been mastered, subjugated. Antheil had taken this hated thing life and rigged himself into power over it by his music - an important difference. By hearing Antheil's music, seemingly so much noise, when I actually came upon noise in reality, I found I had gone up over it.
Anderson neutral, Antheil in a largish room
- ANTHEIL
- As I was to put into the mouth of a character in my opera Transatlantic: New York - heartless city of steel - I was too weak to conquer you - only hearts made of steel can do that, while my heart was made of flesh only. Glare! Heartless Glare! Ah, let me know only the truth of night, everlasting night!
- ANDERSON
- The next time I saw George in Paris, he told me he was writing a detective novel. "What about?" I asked, surprised at this new turn to his career. "The murder of a concert agent" he growled.
Neutral
- "BOGART"
- Wayson opened the apartment door to me. For a DP he was visibly excited. "I've got something for you, I cant at all make out," he said, leading the way thru the living-room where 4 young people sat silent in shock. I could see at a glance there'd been a party. Had liquor been served? It was crucial question.
-
We past into a bedroom. There lay a sensitive, dark-haired, but slightly bald young man, sprawled across the bed in a nasty patch of wet crimson. Exactly in the middle of the forehead was a bullet hole. "We're looking for a real good marksman," drawled Wayson. "It musta been someone he knew & trusted."
"So the extraordinary young concert manager has perished," I replied coldly.
Anderson neutral, Antheil in a largish room
- ANDERSON
- Death in the Dark, was eventually published by Pound's old protégé TS Eliot, now an Editor at Faber's in London.
- ANTHEIL
- O, to save you wondering, it was the soloist's wife that 'done him wrong'!
- ANDERSON
- But the 20s were drawing to an end. It had been an easy, quick, adventurous age, good to be young in; and yet on coming out of it one felt a sense of relief, as on coming out of a room too full of talk and into the sunlight of the winter streets.
-
A new American generation had grown up in Paris, displacing the first wave of post-war émigrés, who in their turn had left in search of exotic settings. Pound had settled in Rapallo, and was already exhibiting signs of the psychosis that would lead to his imprisonment. Scott & Zelda Fitzgerald, that symbolic pairing of the 20's, were beginning their long, slow, unmourned descent into madness and motion picture scripting.
Just as The Crash dislocated everyone's financial preconceptions, so Hemingway's invention of The 'Writer As Hero' exploded America's reliance on European cultural models. In 1929 I closed up The Little Review. There was no longer anything worth reviewing.
-
ANTHEIL
-
My response to the situation was an Opera about political corruption in an American Presidential campaign called Transatlantic. It was premiered at Frankfurt in May 1930, and attended by Irving Schwerké who had earlier been so hostile to my Violin Sonatas:
In his phone booth
- SCHWERKE
- Mr Antheil's new opera employs, as thematic material, motives from some well know American popular ditties. And with felicitous results. It is dynamic throbbing music and the tunes are the kind that everybody wants to whistle. Orchestrated in a manner which a short time back was considered ultra-modern, but which today sounds quite classical, the score discloses how theatrical and emotional present day rhythm and idioms can be when worked with by a composer whose technique and insight are big enough to get out of them what Antheil has. Magnificently staged, Transatlantic is one of the most exciting and convincing theatrical essays that the young school of any nation has to boast of. America should be proud.
Anderson neutral, Antheil in a largish room
- ANTHEIL
- By normal standards, Transatlantic would have been assured of a long happy life on the many German opera stages. But as Hitler clawed his way ever closer to power faint-hearted local governments began to throw out their stout-hearted theatre Intendants, and by the end of the season there was not a single one who dared to permit the performance, on German money, of the work of so dangerous a political personality.
- ANDERSON
- The brilliant reception of this new opera proved exactly nothing to New York or Paris since it was not seen to be repeated, and those cities were in no mood to split hairs about Antheil. Either he was a great success once again or he wasn't.
-
With the capitalist world in the grip of Recession, George began to negotiate a permanent return to America with a project which he desperately hoped would restore his reputation in the eyes of the musical establishment. But alas, Antheil's choice of librettist for his opera Helen retires -tho poetically & diplomatically astute- was dramatically disastrous. And the critics unanimously pasted him 'bad boy of music' once and for all.
Now things looked bleak indeed. Effectively barred from the world of serious music, George was to have considerable success with ballet scores for Balanchine & Graham tho his idiom had now assumed its mature form.
MUS 14 Either CAPITAL OF THE WORLD or LA FEMME 100 TETES Establish then dialog over
- ANDERSON
- Even in this area, George now found himself in the shadow of his exact contemporary and friend Aaron Copland, who was rapidly consolidating his position as the leading younger American composer. Stokowski & Fritz Reiner both showed interest in George's Opera but kept him waiting months for a decision: a little teaching came his way, but not enough to live on. He began to think about Film Music, but not with favour.
Antheil-Bok acoustic
- ANTHEIL
- Am I, Mary Louise, who made practically the only composing reputation in Europe during the last decade, and who actually influenced the trend of certain European music - am I then to come back to America, go thru a year of terrible struggles, heart-aches, disappointments, and terrific work, only to end up in Hollywood? It seem silly to educate a composer for that.
- MRS BOK
- Dear George, there are so many fine and noble things in this great country of ours that I am at a loss to understand why you will choose to portray the sordid aspects of American life in your music. Yet knowing how badly up against it you and your wife are I have decided to re-commence your regular monthly stipend for a time. But I must tell you frankly that I am doing this on humanitarian grounds alone, and not from any faith in your musical gift which faith has, alas, become nil.
- ANTHEIL
- Oh Mary Louise, If I had just $5000 I could prove to the world that my music deserves a real place in the plan of things of this age.
- MRS BOK
- Replying to your letter of September 25th, I must say it is no different than letters I have received from you over a long period of years, and while I am sorry to put any further discouragements in your path, I do not feel inclined to do what you ask, as it would imply an interest in your work I really no longer have.
-
What I did for you financially in those first years I did with hope. But not once has musical opinion favoured your output. And as for your recent opera Helen Retires I know no one at the Juilliard that has either pleasure, interest, or respect for the score.
In all your arguments you quite evidently place the blame for your lack of success anywhere but on yourself. Your egoism has displeased me for it transcends rational self-confidence, nor have the successes you have quoted in your many letters ever had the endorsement of those whose judgment I trust.
Now, my dear George, it is high time for you to make up your mind to stand upon your own feet and make your own living. I have at least 200 musical children who need my interest and support, and it is really not fair to them if I continue to give money to a man whose music I cannot endorse. I am sorry.
Anderson neutral, Antheil in a largish room
- ANDERSON
- Yet Mrs Bok did not in fact stop supporting him until 1937, by which time she had subsidised Antheil to the tune of $40,000 over and above his at-times substantial earnings. But meanwhile, Hollywood beckoned.
-
Following their great success with The Front Page Ben Hecht & Charlie MacArthur had taken up residence in Los Angeles, first as motion picture writers and latterly as producers.
-
ANTHEIL
-
A friend put my name forward to Hecht as a composer. By absolute chance, he had been in the audience of one of my riotous early piano recitals in Budapest when I had produced that famous revolver and ordered the attendants to lock the doors! Remembering this, Hecht immediately realised I was well suited to the film industry!
My introduction to Hecht-MacArthur Pictures outdid anything the Marx Brothers ever put up on the screen. Going to their offices, I chatted with Ben, who offered me the Post of Musical Director. When I tentatively asked what the salary would be, he said "Let me introduce you to our President, he alone decides all matters of this kind." So he took me to the next room which was marked PRESIDENT and told me to go in. I advanced to the desk, where a little pin-headed gentleman in a high wing collar was writing. He did not even look up. I advanced farther, without any response, until I was close enough to see what he was writing.
To my surprise he was just doodling. But suddenly, in a single movement, he looked up at me and jumped right over the desk, jabbering incoherently! He was a pinhead, hired by Ben & Charlie from the local circus to divert people's minds from unpleasant questions.
On the walls of their own office were 2 huge signs, one read "Is The Public In On Our Secret?", the other "Cut To The Chase." Admirable advice to any writer, and probably the nearest thing to sanity I ever encountered in their remarkable company.
MUS 15 4th SYMPHONY Establish & Hold under
- ANDERSON
- Antheil was to remain in Los Angeles for the rest of his life working alternately on his own music and film scores. Of which the 2 most famous neatly span his career - The Plainsman for De Mille in 1936, and 20 years later Stanley J Kramer's first big success The Pride & the Passion.
-
George wrote a number of Symphonies after his return to America - which were premiered consecutively by Stokowski, Ormandy, Monteux & Dorati- as well as Operas and Concertos. Critics were frequently enthusiastic ...
-
US CRITIC
-
Manhattan's Radio City witnessed an almost unprecedented musical event - a new US Symphony that failed to bore its audience. It was also testimony that Composer Antheil, once #1 bad boy of US musical Dadaism, had come home. And was easily the loudest and liveliest symphonic composition to turn up in years.
Antheil's 4th proved what some had long suspected: that the talent Antheil has hid under a bushel of aestheticism is one of the most robust in modern music.
MUS 15 concludes
- ANDERSON
- Despite such reviews, Antheil never succeeded in re-establishing the premier position in American music that once had seemed to be his.
-
Since George's death of a heart attack in 1959 there have been many thoughtful obituaries, of which the most candid was his old friend Virgil Thomson's.
With appropriate acoustics
- THOMSON
- My estimate of him as 'the first composer of our generation' might have been justified had it not turned out eventually that for all his facility and ambition there was in him no power of growth. This 'bad boy of music' merely grew up to be a good boy.
- WILLIAMS
- In his career George confronted many of the issues that have become recurrent dilemmas for creative artists' since - most significantly that of 'post-modernism'. Nowadays, the instruments he demanded would no longer seem at all extraordinary. His real misfortune was to be ahead of his time in undergoing these experiences, and to become discouraged.
- ANDERSON
- Having been effectively born with a strikingly avantgarde compositional style George found it impossible to mature within it because, as Pound and others realised, its logical direction was in the direction of an aesthetic of 'pure sound' from which he shied away. They hoped he would be their standard-bearer and it is interesting to speculate whether Antheil's refusal to accept this role was due to a mature preference for traditional musical forms or because he retained an immature desire to be acknowledged as 'a leading composer' without being prepared to face up to the ruthless self-appraisal that alone could have commanded the respect of his peers.
- WILLIAMS
- By choosing to return to symphonic forms George was competing for attention in an arena which progressive audiences had already deserted. The cruellest thing you might say is that his life was spent in search of role-models: at first Stravinsky, and later Shostakovich. Whatever. The inescapable truth is that Antheil needed other people's approval too much ever to be the real revolutionary, 'cause its a pretty lonely job you know.
- COPLAND
- There are immense similarities with Varèse, but the direction in which each crossed the Atlantic is symbolic. But whereas Varèse came from Europe to 'the New World' with an empirical approach to sound from which he fashioned a new aesthetic, George went with a new concept of music to 'the Old World' but ended up entangled in those very roots from which Varèse was struggling to escape.
- THOMSON
- Well. George's life illustrates in the starkest way how the camp followers of music, the businessmen & critics, are incapable of accepting any fundamental alteration in a composer's self-image. He has my sympathy. I think we ought to pay more attention to him. On the other hand, you could also say people weren't ready for him. I've lived at lot longer than he did, so I guess they may be now.
MUS 16 Ballet Mécanique Pianola Version (if available)
American research by Julia Landau.
Antheil's early piano music was sequenced on a digitally-controlled piano by Maxwell Steer.
The singer was Nancy Hadden.
|
|
 |
 |
|
|
 |
|
|